workplace investigations accountability

Accountability is a common thread in workplace investigations. As independent investigators, we are often retained by clients seeking to be accountable to workers by fulfilling their duty to investigate claims of harassment.[1]  Accountability is mandated by legislation.[2] It also underlies workplace policies and procedures. However, where accountability really comes alive is in the evidence-gathering and fact-finding stages of an investigation. It can be of value to consider whether the parties’ conduct aligns with principles of accountability.

Charlotte V.O. Witvliet et al. assert that accountable people possess the following attributes:

  1. Accountable people seek to know the expectations of people with the standing to hold them accountable.
  2. They are not reluctantly responsive, but rather willingly answer and fulfill their responsibilities to people who justly hold them accountable.
  3. They are transparent and honest with people to whom they are accountable, neither withholding information nor presenting only favourable information about themselves.
  4. They are neither automatically dismissive of nor servile in conforming to whatever people tell them to do, but rather discern whether goals are good – wisely questioning, resisting, and/or reporting when people try to hold them accountable in inappropriate ways or with inappropriate goals.
  5. They value and respect the people to whom they are accountable and those impacted by their actions or inactions.
  6. They welcome learning how to improve, modify, and correct their behavior based on input or feedback.
  7. They are willing to accept their responsibility even when it is difficult or costly to them.
  8. Accountable people see it as good that they fulfill what is properly owed to those to whom they are accountable.[3]

 

Did the parties behave like accountable people? If not, will a claim of harassment be substantiated?

Sometimes, the party complaining of harassment will turn out to be the party who failed to act accountably. Supervisory harassment is a common claim we are retained to investigate. We often hear from workers who feel that they have been harassed by their supervisor when the supervisor has taken reasonable steps to provide feedback and direction to them.

According to Witvliet et al. accountable people “welcome learning how to improve, modify, and correct their behavior based on input or feedback.”[4] The Occupational Health and Safety Act (the “Act”) recognizes that it is important for employers and supervisors to be able to hold workers accountable in this way. Thus, the Act carves out a managerial exception to workplace harassment based on reasonable action taken by an employer or supervisor relating to the management and direction of workers or the workplace.[5]

Sometimes, a supervisor will be found to have acted uncivilly or with hostility towards the worker regarding the manner in which they have exercised their managerial authority. Other times, the supervisor may be found to have acted beyond the scope of their managerial authority. Whether the supervisor’s conduct rises to the level of statutory harassment will be fact specific. Nevertheless, conduct that falls short of statutory harassment could still be found to breach an institutional policy and attract some form of corrective or disciplinary action.

It is important to recognize that accountable leaders foster accountable workers. Leaders must exercise their managerial authority in a way that is reasonable. Leaders should “value and respect the people to whom they are accountable and those impacted by their actions or inactions.”[6] Workers who feel valued and respected are unlikely to reciprocate by making claims of supervisory harassment.

 

How can investigators use the concept of accountability in their practice?

Investigators can use the concept of accountability to guide their fact-finding and analysis. Investigators may find this concept particularly helpful when conducting credibility assessments, as credible witnesses tend to share a lot in common with accountable people. Like accountable people, credible witnesses will tend to be those who are “transparent and honest” with the investigator, “neither withholding information nor presenting only favorable information about themselves.”[7] Not every respondent will be “willing to accept their responsibility even when it is difficult or costly to them”,[8] nor will every complainant. Thus, it is incumbent on the investigator to understand what accountability demands of each party in response to each allegation. Independent investigators are ultimately accountable for treating the parties in a manner that is procedurally fair and for making findings that are fair and defensible.

[1] The Occupational Health and Safety Act (“OHSA”) places an obligation on employers to take all reasonable steps to provide a workplace free from harassment and violence. The OHSA requires that an investigation “appropriate in the circumstances” be undertaken. Occupational Health and Safety Act, RSO 1990, c O.1, s. 32.0.7 (1). Relatedly, the Human Rights Code (the “Code”) places an obligation on employees to ensure that employees are not subject to harassment or discrimination based on certain protected grounds. In the human rights context, case law has developed a procedural duty to investigate. The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario has held that “employers are obliged to take reasonable steps to address complaints of workplace human rights violations, including sexual harassment and sexual solicitation.” Crete v Aqua-Drain Sewer Services Inc, 2017 HRTO 354 at para. 43. In other words, employers have a duty to investigate.

 

Footnotes:

[1] The Occupational Health and Safety Act (“OHSA”) places an obligation on employers to take all reasonable steps to provide a workplace free from harassment and violence. The OHSA requires that an investigation “appropriate in the circumstances” be undertaken. Occupational Health and Safety Act, RSO 1990, c O.1, s. 32.0.7 (1). Relatedly, the Human Rights Code (the “Code”) places an obligation on employees to ensure that employees are not subject to harassment or discrimination based on certain protected grounds. In the human rights context, case law has developed a procedural duty to investigate. The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario has held that “employers are obliged to take reasonable steps to address complaints of workplace human rights violations, including sexual harassment and sexual solicitation.” Crete v Aqua-Drain Sewer Services Inc, 2017 HRTO 354 at para. 43. In other words, employers have a duty to investigate. 

[2]  See footnote 1, above.

[3] Charlotte V.O. Witvliet et al., “Accountability: Construct definition and measurement of a virtue vital to flourishing” (2023) 18.5 The J of Pos Psych 660 at p. 661.

[4] Charlotte V.O. Witvliet et al., “Accountability: Construct definition and measurement of a virtue vital to flourishing” (2023) 18.5 The J of Pos Psych 660 at p. 661 (attribute 6).

[5] Occupational Health and Safety Act, RSO 1990, c O.1, s. 1(4).

[6] Charlotte V.O. Witvliet et al., “Accountability: Construct definition and measurement of a virtue vital to flourishing” (2023) 18.5 The J of Pos Psych 660 at p. 661 (attribute 5).