MrBeast's Burden

In case you’ve never heard of Mr. Beast, you are not alone. However, he and his channel are likely the biggest YouTube stars that you’ve never heard of. Mr. Beast, otherwise known as Jimmy Donaldson, began streaming YouTube videos in 2012. Today, he has built Mr. Beast into a conglomerate of hundreds of employees and multiple channels.

With over 300 million subscribers, his is the most watched channel on the platform. If you’re inclined to scoff at that reach, think again. According to a Forbes online profile in 2022, MrBeast (as his username is written), then in his early 20s, was worth over $50M USD, and the Mr. Beast brand recently signed a deal with Prime Video for a large-scale interactive game show with a $5M USD prize.

Naturally, a following that large is not without some controversy, and a recent incident involving one of Mr. Beast’s employees made headlines far and beyond the YouTube website. One of Mr. Beast’s co-hosts on the platform, a trans woman named Ava Kris Tyson, was let go from her employment after allegations arose of inappropriate messages being sent to minors.

The story itself is full of twists and turns including multiple internet platforms, a variety of screen names, and changing testimony from the alleged victims. However, it is the conflicting statements put out by Donaldson and Tyson about the termination, and the commencement of a workplace investigation, that may shed greater light on best practices.

 

First, A Bit Of Background

Along with YouTube, the Mr. Beast brand is also popular on the streaming platform Twitch, which is where Tyson was most involved with the brand. As an openly trans woman who publicly announced her transition in 2023, Tyson was not without controversy on the platform, but Donaldson and Mr. Beast had stood behind her completely and offered unconditional support.

In late July, 2024, rumours began to circulate that Tyson had sent inappropriate messages to minors through social media platforms some years ago. The practice, known as ‘grooming,’ is where adults will lure underage internet users into an inappropriate sexual relationship, either online or in person, through a series of escalating messages that initially build trust and confidence as a tool to manipulate the relationship.

On July 23, in response to the allegations, Tyson released the following statement on X (formerly Twitter), saying in part: “I would like to apologize for any of my past behavior or comments if it hurt or offended anyone. It was not my intent. Seeing recent events we’ve mutually decided it’s best I permanently step away from all things MrBeast and social media to focus on my family and mental health.”

However, Tyson staunchly denied allegations of grooming, stating that she had “never groomed anyone,” and adding “I humbly apologise to anyone I have hurt with my unacceptable social media posts, past actions, and to those who may feel betrayed by how I used to act online. To lump these two factors together to create a narrative that my behavior extended beyond bad edgy jokes is disgusting and did not happen. In past years, I have learned that my old humor is not acceptable.”

In summary, it appeared that while Ms. Tyson vehemently denied the worst of the allegations made against her, she also chose to voluntarily step away from the platform, and that her resignation was a ‘mutual decision.’

Except, as is so often the case, there turned out to be more to the story.

 

The Employer’s Workplace Investigation

While Ms. Tyson’s statement was crafted to make the resignation look collaborative, the statement released by Donaldson under his Mr. Beast moniker tells a different story. It reads:

Over the last few days, I’ve become aware of the serious allegations of Ava Tyson’s behavior online and I am disgusted and opposed to such unacceptable acts. During that time, I have been focused on hiring an independent third party to conduct a thorough investigation to ensure I have all the facts. That said, I’ve seen enough online and taken immediate action to remove Ava from the company, my channel, and any association with MrBeast. I do not condone or support any of the inappropriate actions.

There are, of course, key differences within the two statements. The first is that Donaldson was concerned enough by the allegations to retain an external workplace investigator to assess whether the allegations are substantiated. It is important to note that the alleged incidents did not take place in Ontario, where an appropriate investigation would be required by law amidst such allegations of harassment. However, to launch such an investigation voluntarily is still a large step.

Second, not only does it appear that Ms. Tyson’s employment ended involuntarily, but that the decision was made to terminate her employment prior to the conclusion of any investigation. In Ontario, it is more customary to place employees on administrative leave during an investigation, however investigations are conducted differently here than in the US. Since the news broke, several internet news sites have reported that evidence has since been made public which proves the allegations against Tyson were at least, in part, accurate.

 

When Personal Meets Professional

 There are some key distinctions in the above scenario, but also some overarching lessons that can apply to employers broadly. The first is that even without legal requirements such as Ontario’s, it would appear that the Mr. Beast team did the right thing by taking any allegations of harassment seriously.

While the circumstances of the allegations may have been unclear at first as to whether or not Tyson was acting in her capacity as an employee during the incidents, that does not necessarily matter. The incidents may have made other colleagues feel unsafe or uncomfortable working alongside Tyson, and that concern alone may be sufficient to trigger an investigation.

Even if Tyson’s alleged conduct was separate and apart from her employment with Mr. Beast, that may not matter when it comes to discipline. As we discussed recently in our post about off-duty conduct, if Tyson had behaved this way while clearly and identifiably an employee of Mr. Beast, that may still impact her employer’s reputation. It is also unclear whether that conduct bled through to the workplace itself.

In any event. Donaldson did the right thing by calling for an investigation, and recruiting a third-party investigator helps ensure that the process is fair and impartial. Employers have an overarching responsibility to keep employees safe, and that includes from harassment and sexual harassment. If an individual is alleged to have engaged in such behaviour, it is imperative to make sure that it is not in any way impacting the workplace.

Donaldson has an additional responsibility as the head of a very public entity. With his level of fame, every decision that the Mr. Beast brand makes comes under intense scrutiny. While he had been publicly supportive of Ms. Tyson in her private life previously, the appearance of being dismissive of such allegations, or sweeping them under the rug, can poison the brand as a whole. The swift move to investigate may be as much of a reputational decision as it was to preserve the safety of the workplace.

There is one final unique point in that the decision to terminate Ms. Tyson’s employment appears to have been made before the investigation was complete. It is unclear exactly what evidence Donaldson had reviewed before making that decision, or whether Tyson will be subject to any further discipline or criminal charges due to her alleged behaviour.

 

Final Thoughts

 The world of the internet is a fast-moving one, and this story may continue to change hourly as new evidence arises. Yet at the crux of the story are some great lessons for employers.

The first is that a workplace investigation can be commenced at the first signs of trouble, and often should be. It is usually impossible to truly gauge the breadth and scope of a problem from the outset, and investigators are trained to do just that. Working with an experienced third-party investigator means that they know the right questions to ask, and the right places to look, to get a complete picture of what has happened.

However, there may be a risk to employers in making decisions on an employee’s future prior to the conclusion of an investigation. Employees may be placed on administrative leave with pay during an investigation, especially if the allegations present a threat to their colleagues, however issuing discipline prior to a completed investigation carries risk for the employer, especially if the allegations against that individual are not substantiated by the findings.

An external investigator can help provide a comprehensive assessment of the situation in ways that you may not be able to see from the inside. Moreover, they can go a step further if retained to do so, and can assess the situation against your policies and procedures, highlighting what gaps allowed such problems to arise in the first place. Contact our office today for more information about how we can help.