Zheng v. Toronto Case Review

Introduction

In a recent case from the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario (“HRTO”), the applicant, Qun Zheng, who identified as Chinese-Canadian, claimed that a staff member at the Crossways Employment Centre (a part of the Toronto Employment & Social Services) refused them service due to their race, ancestry, place of origin, or ethnic origin.

 

The Alleged Incident

The core of this dispute revolved around an incident on March 28, 2018, when the applicant attended the Crossways Employment Centre. The standard check-in process involved scanning a QR Code, which the applicant was having technical difficulty with. The applicant asked a front desk staff member, Teresa Mateus (“Ms. Mateus”) for help but she was unable to locate their name in the system. The applicant testified that they repeated their name numerous times, and that Ms. Mateus “refused services” to them based on hearing their name and accent. The applicant further testified that while repeating their name multiple times, Ms. Mateus stated, “You are rude and speak English with a strong accent.” The applicant stated that a security guard then approached them and “did not allow [them] to use the service either.” The applicant characterized this interaction as a refusal of service due to them identifying as Chinese Canadian.

Ms. Mateus stated that it was not uncommon to be unable to locate a name in the system due to various reasons. She testified she made several attempts to correct the name, but the applicant became loud and entered her personal space. Ms. Mateus testified that she had to move her head back as the applicant had entered her space as she sat at her desk.

Ms. Mateus testified that, upon the applicant becoming “noticeably louder” and “entering her personal space,” she left the desk to go get her supervisor to help find their information. She denied making a comment regarding the applicant’s accent. She also provided evidence that she regularly worked with individuals who have accents due to her role.

A security guard, John Ganzon (“Mr. Ganzon”), testified that he came to the front desk area after he heard raised voices. He stated that the applicant then left voluntarily, without Mr. Ganzon asking them to.  The applicant acknowledged that they came back 30 minutes after this interaction but did not attempt to be serviced.

 

Credibility and Findings

In assessing the credibility of the participants, the Adjudicator ultimately preferred the evidence of the respondent’s witnesses. The Tribunal found it unlikely that Ms. Mateus made the alleged comment about the applicant’s accent, calling it “unnatural.” In support of this finding, the Tribunal cited Ms. Mateus’s experience with diverse accents and the applicant’s inability upon cross-examination to recall exactly what was said. The Tribunal also found that Ms. Mateus leaving her desk was not a refusal of service, but rather, an attempt to get help. This was supported by the fact that the applicant admitted to raising their voice at Ms. Mateus.  Overall, the Tribunal found that the applicant was not refused service. The Tribunal noted that any difficulties the applicant may have encountered after this were due to their own actions in raising their voice, entering Ms. Mateus’s personal space, and voluntarily leaving, rather than related to their protected characteristics.

 

The Duty to Investigate

The applicant also alleged that the respondent failed to satisfy its duty to investigate their complaint. On February 19, 2019, 11 months after the incident, the applicant reached out to the Manager of Employment and Social Services with their allegations. The Manager responded the same day and promised a written response. A response letter was sent to the applicant on March 11, 2019. The Tribunal reviewed internal emails showing that the Manager conducted in-person meetings with relevant staff, including Mr. Ganzon, immediately after receiving the applicant’s emails.

The Tribunal acknowledged that the caselaw is “far from settled as to whether there is a duty to investigate in service relationships.” However, it found that even if such duty exists, it was satisfied in this case, and a reasonable investigation did occur.

 

Conclusion

The Tribunal dismissed the applicant’s application, concluding that they failed to prove, on a balance of probability, that race, ancestry, place of origin, or ethnic origin were factors in their experience of not receiving services.